Red Dead Redemption 2 Legendary fish locations and how to catch them

Red Dead Redemption 2 Legendary Fish are the most valuable catches you can find out in the world.

Similar to Legendary Animals, these are rare, challenging finds that require a slightly different approach than regular fishing.

Unlike the list of Legendary Animals – which is unlocked during an unmissable story mission in Chapter Two – the list required to begin hunting Legendary Fish is resigned to a Stranger mission. This stranger is one Jeremy Gill, who can be found fishing (obviously) on the pier on the northeast shore of Flat Iron Lake.

In order to complete the Legendary Fish quest ‘Fisher of Fish’, you’ll need to lure and catch all 13 specimens. However, you’ll also need to mail every one to Mr Gill in order to properly check them off. You can do this at any Post Office.

There are a total of 13 Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2, each one representing the pinnacle of its species. Each one is unique and one-off, so once you’ve caught each one, it will no longer be available (much like the Legendary Animals).

There is also a special hidden fish, but you can only catch this specimen if you complete the following criteria:

Once these two factors have been met, you’ll be invited to a trip in Rio Bravo to catch the Channel Catfish.

Here’s a list of Legendary Fish encounters you can find:

Legendary Fish location: Dakota River, northwest of Flatneck Station.

Recommended Lure: Special River Lure

Legendary Fish location: Southern railroad bridge leading to Saint Denis (stand on the edge of the bridge to avoid trains).

Recommended Lure: Special River Lure

Legendary Fish location: Lagras, at the northwest tip of the Lakay peninsula.

Recommended Lure: Special Swamp Lure

Legendary Fish location: Van Horn Trading Post, at the foot of the lighthouse.

Recommended Lure: Special River Lure

Legendary Fish location: Elysian Pool, to the southwest of Annesburg.

Recommended Lure: Special Lake Lure

Legendary Fish location: Owanjila Lake, just west of Strawberry.

Recommended Lure: Special Lake Lure

Legendary Fish location: Lake Isabella, at the west edge of the Grizzlies.

Recommended Lure: Special Lake Lure

Legendary Fish location: Willard’s Rest, by the waterfall at the northeast edge of the world map, directly north of Annesburg.

Recommended Lure: Special River Lure

Legendary Fish location:
Flat Iron Lake, between the shore and the island to the south of Clemens Point.

Recommended Lure: Special Lake Lure

Legendary Fish location: Sisika Island, just west of the penitentiary.

You’ll need a rowboat to reach Sisika. These are mostly random, and quite rare at times. We found this one in the wetlands east of Saint Denis.

Recommended Lure: Special River Lure

Legendary Fish location: Aurora Basin’s pier, to the east of Blackwater.

Recommended Lure: Special Lake Lure

Legendary Fish location: Stillwater Creek, in the largest basin, to the east of MacFarlane’s Ranch.

Recommended Lure: Special Lake Lure

Legendary Fish location: San Luis River, just southeast of Lake Don Julio.

Recommended Lure: Special River Lure

There’s plenty of ways to prepare for Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2:

Best Lures for Legendary Fish

There are lots of lures to choose from in Red Dead Redemption 2, including nine regular ones and four special ones. As you might imagine, the nine normal lures won’t be of any use to you when fishing for Legendary Fish. So you’ll need to utilise the four remaining ones to bag these unique, one-off catches. These lures are:

In order to increase your chances of catching the Legendary Fish you’re currently seeking, make sure you equip the Special Bait that relates to the body of water you’re using. Doing the opposite will actively reduce your success rate.

Best way to catch Legendary Fish

As mentioned above, reeling in Legendary Fish is not easy and takes much longer per catch. This means there’s a greater chance of the line snapping, so you’ll really need to be vigilant if you want to ensure your catch isn’t temporarily lost. To do this, you’ll need to use the ‘advanced reeling-in technique’.

So when a Legendary Fish is tired and no longer thrashing in the water, tilt the left analog stick back to pull your rod up, then quickly reel in with the right analog stick (spin the stick clockwise).

Repeat this every time the fish rests as it will draw the fish in a little faster and give you an edge in each watery duel. Try and find a hand position for the reeling that suits you – Legendary Fish battles can last a few minutes, so try using the pads of you middle and index finger to rotate the stick faster and more consistently.

Other things that can improve your chances of catching Legendary Fish in Red Dead Redemption 2:

Need more help?

If you’re looking for things to collect, there’s Dinosaur Bone locations, Dreamcatcher locations, Killer Clue Piece locations, as well as Jack Hall Gang Treasure Map locations and the Poisonous Trail Treasure Map locations.

Fancy something a little more involved? We can explain how to get perfect pelts, hides and skins as well as all Legendary Animal locations and Legendary Fish locations.

And if you’re after upgrades, there’s how to get Gold Bars fast, the best horse, the best Red Dead Redemption 2 weapons, satchel upgrades and camp upgrades.

Finally, a list of Red Dead Redemption 2 cheat codes and an idea of the Red Dead Online beta date. Not long now!

In order to keep you engrossed in the quest to catch all 13 Legendary Fish, Mr Gill will reward you at certain milestones. There are three rewards to unlock over the course of this mission, but they can only be earned once you’ve mailed the respective number of catches. These are as follows:

Wait 24 in-game hours after posting the 13th Legendary Fish, then an invitation from Jeremy Gill with arrive at any post office. Head back to the marker on the map (where the Fisher of Fish mission first started) and Jeremy will invite you to catch another mythical water-dweller.

You’ll now travel to the Rio Bravo, and use a camera to capture Jeremy’s crowning glory at the water’s edge. Unfortunately, his prey ends up pulling him into the water, and nothing is left of him bar his special hat. This completes the ‘Fisher of Fish’ questline and awards you with the Special Spinner lure.

You don’t have to catch the Catfish as the quest is now complete (the Legendary Fish section of the Total Completion record will now be ticked – found via Progress in the pause menu), but a marker does remain on the map for fisherman brave enough to try…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *